How important is objectivity, ethics and accuracy in historical fiction?
Recently I was critical of the semi-historical approach used in Kate Grenville’s latest novel The Lieutenant. However, a couple more books down the track I’m reading Richard Flanagan’s Wanting, another work of fiction based on historical fact. In many ways I think the aspects of The Lieutenant that I think failed are the most rewarding elements of Wanting. I’ll elaborate on this in my comments on Flanagan’s book when I finishing it.
However, my subjectivity of individual books aside, this raises are much more important issue about writers who dabble in historical fiction. A question of objectivity, ethics and accuracy. Grenville and Flanagan are primarily writing for an adult audience, but what of the writers who write for a youth readership. Those in the midst of their education?
Nadia Wheatley does just this. I have never read her books but this interview with her readers she touches on the very heart of the issue. Check it out.
